It was supposed to be another beautiful summer day on the lake. A family enjoying the sunshine, children laughing, and hours spent swimming, wakeboarding, and making memories together.
But for one Oklahoma mother, that ordinary family outing turned into a tragedy she could never have imagined.
Cassi Free lost her 9-year-old son, Andrew “Andy” Brady Free, after he was exposed to deadly levels of carbon monoxide while riding on the family’s boat.
The most frightening part? The family was outdoors, surrounded by fresh air and open water.
They had no idea that an invisible, odorless gas could accumulate around their boat and become deadly.
Now, his mother is sharing her family’s experience to warn other parents about a little-known danger called open-air carbon monoxide poisoning.
Her message is especially important for anyone who enjoys boating, water sports, or spending time near motorized watercraft.
A Family Lake Trip That Ended in Tragedy
On June 6, 2020, Cassi Free, her husband, and their three sons were enjoying a day at Lake Eufaula in Oklahoma.
The family had years of boating experience. Spending time on the water was a familiar part of their lives.
That day, they were joined by friends and participated in several water activities, including tubing, wakeboarding, and wakesurfing.
Andy, the youngest of the three boys, was an experienced swimmer who had been wakeboarding since he was just three years old.
Nothing about the day initially suggested that something dangerous was happening.
But as the family began returning toward the dock, the children grew increasingly tired.
The boat was moving slowly through a no-wake zone, and Andy had spent time near the rear of the vessel, an area where engine exhaust can accumulate under certain conditions.
As the family prepared to leave, Andy crawled toward the back of the boat and lay down.
Moments later, he fell into the water.
At first, the adults did not immediately understand what had happened.
But when Andy failed to resurface, they knew something was terribly wrong.
Family members jumped into the water, recovered him, and attempted CPR.
Despite their efforts, the little boy could not be revived. 2 News Oklahoma KJRH Tulsa+1
Doctors Initially Believed He Had Drowned
When Andy was taken to the hospital, his death was initially understood to be a drowning.
However, something else happened that made his mother question that explanation.
His two older brothers began experiencing concerning symptoms, including headaches, dizziness, and nausea.
Both were taken to the hospital, where doctors discovered they had suffered acute carbon monoxide poisoning.
This finding raised a disturbing possibility.
Could Andy have been exposed to the same invisible gas?
An autopsy later revealed that Andy had a carboxyhemoglobin level of approximately 72%.
Carboxyhemoglobin forms when carbon monoxide binds to hemoglobin in the blood, preventing it from carrying oxygen normally.
A level that high indicates extremely severe poisoning.
Investigators determined that carbon monoxide exposure had rendered Andy unconscious, contributing to his drowning.
The danger had not come from the water itself.
It had come from the boat’s exhaust. 2 News Oklahoma KJRH Tulsa+2
The Hidden Danger Most Boaters Don’t Know About
Many people associate carbon monoxide poisoning with enclosed spaces such as garages, homes, or poorly ventilated rooms.
However, carbon monoxide can also accumulate outdoors.
Gasoline-powered boat engines and generators produce carbon monoxide as a byproduct of combustion.
Under certain conditions, exhaust gases can collect around the rear of a boat, near swim platforms, or even in open seating areas.
This is especially concerning when a boat is traveling slowly, idling, or operating in conditions that cause exhaust gases to circulate back toward passengers.
The phenomenon is sometimes called the station wagon effect or backdrafting.
Instead of dispersing harmlessly into the surrounding air, exhaust gases may be drawn back toward the vessel.
People sitting near the rear of the boat can unknowingly inhale dangerous concentrations.
Because carbon monoxide has no color, smell, or taste, victims may have no warning before symptoms begin.
The CDC confirms that carbon monoxide can reach deadly concentrations around certain boat exhaust areas, even in open air. CDC+1
The Early Warning Signs Can Be Mistaken for Exhaustion
One reason carbon monoxide poisoning is particularly dangerous during outdoor activities is that its early symptoms resemble common complaints associated with spending a long day in the sun.
Someone exposed to the gas might simply say they feel tired or need to lie down.
Other symptoms can include:
- Headache or unusual pressure in the head.
- Dizziness or difficulty maintaining balance.
- Nausea and vomiting.
- Sudden weakness or unexplained fatigue.
- Confusion or difficulty concentrating.
- Drowsiness or unusual sleepiness.
- Loss of consciousness in severe cases.
During a summer boating trip, these symptoms can easily be mistaken for dehydration, motion sickness, heat exhaustion, or general tiredness.
That confusion can delay emergency medical treatment.
The CDC warns that severe carbon monoxide exposure can cause unconsciousness, allowing a person to fall into the water and drown. CDC
Why Children May Be Especially Vulnerable
Children exposed to carbon monoxide can become seriously ill, particularly when concentrations are high.
Their symptoms may also be difficult to recognize because younger children cannot always explain exactly how they feel.
They might become unusually quiet, sleepy, irritable, or less responsive.
A child complaining of a headache or nausea after a day on the water may appear to be experiencing ordinary fatigue.
However, if several passengers develop similar symptoms around the same time, carbon monoxide exposure should be considered immediately.
In Andy’s case, his two older brothers also suffered poisoning.
Their symptoms helped reveal what had happened to their younger brother.
The family had unknowingly been exposed to a dangerous environment while participating in an activity they had enjoyed for years.
A Mother’s Mission to Prevent Another Tragedy
After losing Andy, Cassi Free began speaking publicly about the dangers of carbon monoxide exposure around boats.
She explained that her family had been experienced boaters, yet they had never understood how exhaust could accumulate around a moving vessel.
Rather than allowing the tragedy to remain a private family loss, she decided to help educate other families.
Her story attracted widespread attention, including national television coverage.
In 2023, she also worked with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to raise awareness among boaters.
During boating safety activities in Oklahoma, she shared Andy’s story and helped families understand how carbon monoxide poisoning can occur in open-air environments.
Her goal was to make sure other parents knew about a danger her own family had never anticipated.
Andy had loved spending time outdoors and participating in water sports.
His mother hopes that educating others about what happened will help protect future generations of children. Good Morning America+2
How to Protect Your Family From Carbon Monoxide Poisoning on Boats
The good news is that boating-related carbon monoxide poisoning is preventable.
Safety organizations, including the CDC and U.S. Coast Guard, recommend several important precautions.
1. Stay away from engine exhaust areas. Never allow children or adults to sit, hang, or play on rear swim platforms while the engine or generator is running.
2. Be especially careful at low speeds. Carbon monoxide can accumulate around a boat when it is idling, moving slowly, or stopped with its engine running.
3. Maintain your boat properly. Have engines, generators, exhaust outlets, and ventilation systems inspected regularly by qualified professionals.
4. Use marine-rated carbon monoxide detectors. Install and maintain appropriate detectors in enclosed boat areas, following manufacturer recommendations. Remember that these alarms do not make exposed outdoor areas safe.
5. Never ignore unexplained symptoms. Headache, nausea, dizziness, or sudden drowsiness should be taken seriously, particularly if multiple passengers become ill.
6. Keep swimmers away from exhaust outlets. Avoid swimming or playing near the rear of boats with running engines or generators.
7. Know what to do in an emergency. If carbon monoxide poisoning is suspected, move everyone to fresh air immediately and contact emergency services. Anyone with suspected exposure needs prompt medical evaluation. CDC+1
What to Do if Someone Shows Signs of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
Carbon monoxide poisoning is a medical emergency.
If someone develops symptoms while boating, do not simply assume they are tired, dehydrated, or seasick.
Immediately move the person away from the suspected exhaust source and into fresh air.
Stop the engine if it is safe to do so, and contact emergency services.
Medical professionals may administer high-concentration oxygen and evaluate the patient’s blood for carbon monoxide exposure.
In some severe cases, hyperbaric oxygen therapy may be considered.
It is important to understand that ordinary fingertip pulse oximeters cannot reliably detect carbon monoxide poisoning. A person can have a deceptively normal oxygen saturation reading despite significant exposure.
Never wait for symptoms to disappear before seeking medical care when poisoning is suspected.
Andy’s Story Is a Warning Every Boating Family Should Hear
The loss of Andrew Brady Free was devastating, but his mother’s decision to share what happened has brought attention to a danger many families still do not recognize.
Carbon monoxide poisoning doesn’t always occur inside a closed garage or poorly ventilated house.
It can happen on a beautiful sunny afternoon, aboard a boat, with fresh air and open water in every direction.
Even experienced boaters may not recognize the signs until it is too late.
And symptoms that appear relatively harmless — a headache, nausea, dizziness, or unusual tiredness — can sometimes indicate a life-threatening emergency.
Final Thoughts
Andy was only nine years old when his life ended during what should have been a happy family outing.
His two brothers survived after receiving medical attention for carbon monoxide poisoning.
Today, his mother’s advocacy continues to remind families that invisible dangers deserve just as much attention as the risks they can easily see.
Before your next lake trip, remember this: You don’t have to be inside a closed space to suffer carbon monoxide poisoning.
Understanding how boat exhaust behaves, recognizing early symptoms, and taking simple safety precautions could save a life.
Sometimes, the most important lesson from a heartbreaking story is the one that prevents another family from experiencing the same loss.
Editor’s note: This incident occurred on June 6, 2020, at Lake Eufaula, Oklahoma. The case continues to be discussed in boating safety campaigns, including renewed media coverage in 2026.
